In short: In System1's early ranking published on 12 November 2026, Morrisons and Sainsbury's share first place with 5.9 stars and a Spike of 1.68 each. Supermarkets hold seven of the twelve slots, and John Lewis's "Gloria and Pickles" is absent — even though System1 scored it 5.6 stars a week earlier, the brand's best result since 2019.

Which Christmas ad of 2026 tops System1's ranking?

Morrisons' "Christmas Made Just Right" and Sainsbury's "Sainsbury's Big Delivery" are joint first: both take the maximum 5.9 stars and the list's highest Spike of 1.68. Behind them come M&S "The Home of Christmas" (5.9 / 1.58), Aldi with Kevin the Carrot (5.9 / 1.51), cider maker Thatchers' first-ever festive film (5.9 / 1.37), Disney's short "The Invisible Horse" (5.9 / 1.34), Barbour with Wallace & Gromit (5.9 / 1.32) and the National Lottery (5.9 / 0.98). Ninth is Coca-Cola's AI-made "Holidays Are Coming" (5.7), tenth is Lidl (5.7). The dozen closes with Tesco's "The Wrong Address" (5.7) and Waitrose's "The Perfect Gift 2", a six-minute romcom sequel with Keira Knightley and Joe Wilkinson (5.6).

Why did John Lewis miss the top 12?

"Gloria and Pickles" launched on 3 November: Dame Kristin Scott Thomas plays the grandmother, Paul Whitehouse voices the wooden pull-along dog, and the soundtrack is Sam Fender's cover of The Rolling Stones' "You Can't Always Get What You Want". Saatchi & Saatchi made it, Lucy Forbes directed. On 4 November System1 gave it 5.6 stars — John Lewis's strongest score since "Excitable Edgar" in 2019 (5.9) and a fourth straight year of improvement after 4.6 in 2024 and 5.1 in 2025. System1 also reported that 61% of viewers felt happy after watching, nearly double the UK TV average. But in the 12 November ranking eight films carry the maximum 5.9 stars and the twelfth-placed Waitrose ad is also on 5.6, so John Lewis sits right on the cut-off line. System1 does not explain its absence or how it separated identical scores, and Asda is missing from the list too.

What do System1's stars actually measure?

System1's Test Your Ad gauges viewers' emotional response. The Star Rating runs from 1.0 to 5.9 and is meant to predict long-term brand building; System1 says only about 1% of ads reach 5 stars in a year. The Spike Rating predicts short-term sales impact. The release discloses no sample size, no test dates and no scores for ads outside the twelve. Earlier System1 tests covered by PPC Land used a nationally representative sample of 150 respondents and the FaceTrace measure, but that is unconfirmed for the Christmas round.

Why did supermarkets beat everyone this year?

Only 0.3 stars separate first from twelfth, so the details decided it: recurring characters and familiar stories. Sainsbury's brings back Roald Dahl's BFG for a third year, Aldi keeps Kevin the Carrot going in his tenth season, Morrisons rewrites Goldilocks and the Three Bears, and Lidl re-sings Slade. The non-retailers in the top are the ones leaning on animation and licensed heroes: Aardman for Thatchers and Barbour, and Disney with director Dougal Wilson.

FAQ

Which 2026 Christmas ad is the most effective?

According to System1's early ranking of 12 November 2026, Morrisons and Sainsbury's are joint first on 5.9 stars with a Spike of 1.68.

What did John Lewis score?

5.6 stars in System1's 4 November test — its highest since 2019, but not enough for the top 12.

Is this the final ranking of the season?

No. It is an early read: System1 tests films as they launch, and full season tables follow later.